Read Our Reviews     |   CALL TODAY! TEXT US!

 Back to Blog

Gas vs. Electric Furnaces for Indiana Homes

As Indiana’s seasons change, homeowners face the crucial decision of how best to heat their homes. With the chill of winter approaching, understanding the differences between gas and electric furnaces is more than just an academic exercise — it’s about comfort, cost, and efficiency.

Whether you’re installing a new system or considering an upgrade, here’s a detailed look at the pros and cons of gas and electric furnaces to guide your decision. And remember, we offer comprehensive gas and electric furnace services, ensuring your home stays warm all winter.

Electric Furnaces

A home high efficiency electric furnace in a basement

Electric furnaces are increasingly becoming a popular choice for homeowners due to their numerous advantages. From safety to ease of installation, these heating systems offer a modern solution for keeping your home warm and comfortable. Let’s delve deeper into the benefits and the issues of choosing an electric furnace for your home heating needs.

Benefits of an Electric Furnace

When considering a heating system for your home, an electric furnace stands out as a compelling option, blending modern technology with efficient design to provide a seamless heating experience. Renowned for their safety, ease of use, and longevity, electric furnaces offer a host of benefits that are attracting more homeowners each year, including:

  • Safety and Simplicity: Electric furnaces don’t rely on combustible fuels, reducing the risks of leaks and carbon monoxide. They are generally considered safer and easier to maintain.
  • Installation: Easier and typically less expensive to install than gas furnaces. They don’t require a gas line and are a good option where natural gas isn’t readily available.
  • Longevity: Electric furnaces can have a longer lifespan than gas furnaces, often lasting up to 20 to 30 years with proper maintenance.

Cons of an Electric Furnace

Though these are celebrated for their safety and simplicity, certain aspects such as operational costs and heating efficiency, might influence your choice. Here’s a closer look at the cons of choosing an electric furnace for your home heating needs:

  • Operational Cost: Electricity costs more than natural gas in many areas, which can lead to higher operational costs.
  • Efficiency: While electric furnaces can efficiently heat a home, they may take longer to reach the desired temperature compared to their gas counterparts.

Gas Furnaces

Gas furnace

When it comes to heating your home, gas furnaces stand out as a reliable and time-tested option, especially suited to the brisk winters of Indiana. Here’s an expanded look at the advantages and considerations of choosing a gas furnace for your heating needs.

Benefits of a Gas Furnace

Gas furnaces stand as a beacon of reliability and efficiency in home heating, particularly in areas prone to biting cold, such as Indiana.

Here’s a more detailed exploration of the benefits that make gas furnaces a go-to choice for homeowners seeking comfort and efficiency:

  • Efficient heating: Gas furnaces provide robust and efficient heating, making them a popular choice in colder regions like Indiana. They heat up quickly and distribute warmth evenly throughout the home.
  • Cost-effective: Natural gas is often less expensive than electricity, meaning operational costs can be lower with a gas furnace.
  • Longevity: With proper maintenance, gas furnaces can have a long operational life, offering a solid return on investment.

Cons of a Gas Furnace

While gas furnaces are lauded for their efficiency and cost-effectiveness, it’s important to acknowledge and understand the potential drawbacks.

Being aware of these challenges can help homeowners make an informed decision and prepare adequately if they choose a gas furnace for their heating needs. Here’s a closer look at the cons associated with gas furnaces:.

  • Installation: Installing a gas furnace can be more complex due to the need for a gas line. This might mean higher initial installation costs.
  • Maintenance: They require regular maintenance to ensure safety and efficiency, including checks for gas leaks and carbon monoxide.
  • Safety considerations: The risk of carbon monoxide leaks, while low with proper maintenance, is a factor to consider.

Making the Right Choice for Your Indiana Home

Choosing between a gas and electric furnace depends on several factors, including your home’s infrastructure, local utility costs, and personal preferences for efficiency, safety, and environmental impact. It’s important to consider both the initial investment and long-term operational costs.

As Indiana’s trusted heating experts, we offer comprehensive services for both gas and electric furnaces. Our team is dedicated to helping you find the most efficient and cost-effective heating solution for your home. Visit our top-level furnace pages for more information and to see how we can help keep your Indiana home cozy and comfortable

Choose Northern Comfort Systems for reliable, efficient, and affordable heating solutions.

Schedule Now

Fill out the form below


Why choose us

Discover the DIfference

7+ years | Rheem team top contractor


24/7 service

2020 winner | Best of
Home Advisor


100% satisfaction

Hear what your
neighbors are saying

Jacques S.

I am very pleased with the installation of a water heater in my basement. The technician was professional throughout the entire process from...

Natalie M.

Northern Comfort has been wonderful. They are very responsive and professional. We purchased a whole home humidifier and air purifier last f...

Beth A.

Professional and courteous service from technician Brandon. Answered all my questions. The annual maintenance contract is affordable and a g...